SETX Directory

Best-Rated Insurance Agencies in Nacogdoches, TX

Top 10 of 53 listings, ranked by rating and review count

We compared 53 Insurance businesses in Nacogdoches, TX; 40 have a rating and review count to rank. The top 3 are Ted Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent (5.0 stars, 494 reviews), Ai united Insurance (5.0 stars, 294 reviews) and Nikki Evans-Wallace - State Farm Insurance Agent (4.9 stars, 211 reviews).

How we rank listings

Compare the latest stored directory ratings. Each business shows its latest rating check when available, or its source import date. Confirm current hours and availability with the business.

Explore every best-rated business type in Nacogdoches

Rating freshness

0 of 10 displayed listings have a rating check from the past 90 days. 10 use source-import dates when available.

Checks cover the stored rating and review count. Confirm current details with the business or review source.

At a glance

#BusinessRatingReviewsScoreSundayOnline booking
1Ted Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent5.04944.98ClosedYes
2Ai united Insurance5.02944.97Closed—
3Nikki Evans-Wallace - State Farm Insurance Agent4.92114.86ClosedYes
4A-MAX Auto Insurance5.0444.81Closed—
5Jamie Rodrigues - State Farm Insurance Agent4.81104.73ClosedYes
6Koonce Insurance Group4.9394.72ClosedYes
7Pronto Insurance4.71404.65Closed—
8Texas Farm Bureau Insurance Company5.0144.58Closed—
9Pronto Insurance4.6874.54Closed—
10Farmers Insurance - Kerry Vaught4.9144.53ClosedYes

Score = (rating × reviews + 40) ÷ (reviews + 10). A dash marks a detail the listing has yet to post.

Build your three-business shortlist

Choose up to three businesses from this page, review their contact details together and take a copy into your next conversation. Your selection stays in this page until you leave or refresh; copy or download it to keep it.

Choose businesses · 0 of 3 selected

Select the businesses you want to compare.

Contact your chosen business to confirm services, timing and terms. Selecting or downloading a shortlist does not send an inquiry. Shortlist instructions

1
210 North St+1 936-564-3260
Comparison score 4.98Online bookingWebsite

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

2
Ai united InsuranceFinancial Services
5(294)
1006 South St+1 936-225-5007
Comparison score 4.97Website

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

3
332 N University Dr+1 936-560-4600
Comparison score 4.86Online bookingWebsite

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

4
A-MAX Auto InsuranceFinancial Services
5(44)
1504 North St+1 936-234-8282
Comparison score 4.81Website

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

5
104 W College St+1 936-564-7000
Comparison score 4.73Online bookingWebsite

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

6
Koonce Insurance GroupFinancial Services
4.9(39)
3801 North St #18+1 936-569-7223
Comparison score 4.72Online bookingWebsite

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

7
Pronto InsuranceFinancial Services
4.7(140)
1006 North St Suite 1+1 936-560-0404
Comparison score 4.65Website

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

8
5026 Tech Dr+1 936-564-7374
Comparison score 4.58Website

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

9
Pronto InsuranceFinancial Services
4.6(87)
818 South St+1 936-585-6222
Comparison score 4.54Website

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

10
4.9(14)
2710 North St+1 936-569-6156
Comparison score 4.53Online bookingWebsite

Source import: Nacogdoches TX. View listing details.

How we rank listings

We sort listings with a recorded rating and review count by a comparison score: (rating × review count + 4 × 10) ÷ (review count + 10). The fixed 4-star baseline and weight of 10 reduce the influence of very small review samples; they are directory settings, not additional customer reviews. Ties use review count, then business name and ID. Listings without both a rating and a positive review count appear afterward. Featured purchases do not affect this order. Ratings are the latest stored directory data; check the business listing and review source for current details.

Best-rated Insurance Agencies in nearby cities

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best-rated insurance agencies in Nacogdoches, TX?

Ranked by our comparison score, the top 3 are Ted Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent (5.0 stars, 494 reviews), Ai united Insurance (5.0 stars, 294 reviews) and Nikki Evans-Wallace - State Farm Insurance Agent (4.9 stars, 211 reviews).

How many insurance agencies in Nacogdoches, TX were compared?

All 53 active listings in Nacogdoches, TX. 40 have a rating and review count, which the score uses, and this page shows the top 10.

How is the ranking calculated?

We sort listings with a recorded rating and review count by a comparison score: (rating × review count + 4 × 10) ÷ (review count + 10). The fixed 4-star baseline and weight of 10 reduce the influence of very small review samples; they are directory settings, not additional customer reviews. Ties use review count, then business name and ID. Listings without both a rating and a positive review count appear afterward. Featured purchases do not affect this order. Ratings are the latest stored directory data; check the business listing and review source for current details.

How can I make a shortlist and contact a business?

Open Build your three-business shortlist, select up to three businesses shown on this page and review their available contact details together. Copy or download your selection before leaving. Contact each business directly to confirm services, availability and terms. Selecting a business does not send an inquiry or create a booking. How to use the shortlist

Which of the top-rated insurance agencies offer online booking?

Of the 10 shown, Ted Smith - State Farm Insurance Agent, Nikki Evans-Wallace - State Farm Insurance Agent, Jamie Rodrigues - State Farm Insurance Agent, Koonce Insurance Group and Farmers Insurance - Kerry Vaught offer online booking.

How can my business appear in this comparison?

Every active listing in Nacogdoches, TX with a rating and review count is ranked automatically. Add your business with a free listing, or claim your existing listing for free, to keep your hours, photos and details current. List your business in Nacogdoches

Local deals & discounts

Explore offers across Southeast Texas

Browse available offers, check eligibility and redemption details, and open the business’s official terms.

Get local deals

You can also join the separate alerts launch list for future promotions. Availability varies by business.